[#MDSAL-271] About Namespace

[MDSAL-271] About Namespace Created: 23/Jun/17 Updated: 16/Mar/19 Resolved: 16/Mar/19
Status:	Resolved
Project:	mdsal
Component/s:	Binding V2 codegen, Binding V2 runtime
Affects Version/s:	None
Fix Version/s:	None

Type:

Bug

Reporter:

Jie Han

Assignee:

Jie Han

Resolution:

Won't Do

Votes:

Labels:

None

Remaining Estimate:

Not Specified

Time Spent:

Not Specified

Original Estimate:

Not Specified

Environment:

Operating System: All
Platform: All

Attachments:

uses-001.png

uses-002.png

uses.png

Issue Links:

Blocks
is blocked by	~~YANGTOOLS-843~~	The schema path should be unique to e...	Resolved

External issue ID:

8731

Description

As in binding2-spec , providing "Data" & "Grouping" suffixs to resolve confliction of type name in the same package,
but this solution has drawbacks, there still exists confliction.

In my opinion, there should also provide the namesapce 'data' and 'grp' at sub levels, just shown right side of '->' below,
although this may result in an even longer package name but it works correctly.

module namespace-test-foo2 {
namespace "org.test.namespace.foo2";
prefix "foo2";
revision 2017-05-19;
/* by Suffix / / by Sub NameSpace */
container a { // data.A -> data.A
container a { // data.a.A -> data.a.data.A
container a

{ // data.a.a.A -> data.a.data.a.data.A }

grouping a

{ // data.a.a.AGrouping -> data.a.data.a.grp.A }

}

grouping a { // data.a.AGrouping -> data.a.grp.A
container a { // data.a.a.AData -> data.a.grp.a.data.A
container a

{ // data.a.a.a.AData -> data.a.grp.a.data.a.data.A }

grouping a

{ // data.a.a.a.AGrouping -> data.a.grp.a.data.a.grp.A }

}

grouping a { // data.a.a.AGrouping -> data.a.grp.a.grp.A
container a

{ // data.a.a.a.AData -> data.a.grp.a.grp.a.data.A }

grouping a

{ // data.a.a.a.AGrouping -> data.a.grp.a.grp.a.grp.A }

}
}
}

grouping a { // grp.AGrouping -> grp.A
container a { // grp.a.AData -> grp.a.data.A
container a

{ // grp.a.a.AData -> grp.a.data.a.data.A }

grouping a

{ // grp.a.a.AGrouping -> grp.a.data.a.grp.A }

}

grouping a { // grp.a.AGrouping -> grp.a.grp.A
container a

{ // grp.a.a.AData -> grp.a.grp.a.data.A }

grouping a

{ // grp.a.a.AGrouping -> grp.a.grp.a.grp.A }

}
}
}

Comments

Comment by Martin Ciglan [ 03/Jul/17 ]

Hi Jie

is this fully working in patches you have pushed? Can you provide links to gerrit? Thanks.