[YANGTOOLS-872] require-instance on leafref is always false in YANG 1.0 models

Sun, 1 Apr 2018 02:30:07 +0000

We have now a device that uses a YANG 1.1 model with require-instance=false on a leafref, so we are trying to make sure that we don't validate this leafref by checking when the LeafrefTypeDefinition.requireInstance() method returns false.

But when we do that, we find that this method returns always false on YANG 1.0 models. This is wrong, because in YANG 1.0 it should behave always as true (although the keyword did not exist then). If not, since the parser does not provide input on whether some leaf is coming from a YANG 1.0 or YANG 1.1 model, we can't know whether requireInstance() is false because it was explicitly set as false, or because the keyword didn't exist.

Attached a small model to reproduce: the "reference" leaf in mycontainer has requireInstance() = false.

We are using Nitrogen SR1 at this moment.

OpenDaylight JIRA

[YANGTOOLS-872] require-instance on leafref is always false in YANG 1.0 models